People who want AI to move faster and people who want it to slow down can be afraid of the same thing. In the debate over AI safety, Dario Amodei has stood out as both a builder of the technology and a voice urging caution about its development. The co-founder of Anthropic, the company behind Claude, believes AI could accelerate discoveries that save lives. In a recent call for AI development to slow down so safeguards can keep pace, he wrote, “My own father died of a disease that was cured just a few years after his death.” Dario knows what it means for progress to arrive too late. And yet he is asking us to slow down.
The ethical question at stake is how much we can sacrifice for the future before we begin to destroy what makes that future worth pursuing.
There is a scene in The Imitation Game that makes this painfully concrete. Alan Turing’s team has broken Enigma, the code protecting German military communications. They discover that a British convoy is about to be attacked. They can send a warning. But Turing argues that doing so will reveal their breakthrough, prompting the Germans to change the code and destroying their chance to use it to win the war.
In the scene, the team has to decide to sacrifice the convoy in order to win the war. After having built a machine to save lives, they now have to defend a decision to let people die.
This week’s parsha complicates this problem and also offers a solution.
In this week’s parsha, Abraham argues with God not to destroy Sodom and Gomorrah. When God tells him what He intends to do, Abraham begins looking for a reason to spare the people who live there. He asks whether fifty righteous people would be enough to save the city, then continues until God agrees to spare it for just ten. Abraham is arguing for people he does not know, including the wicked neighbors who would be saved alongside the righteous. Their lives are worth defending even when their behavior is not.
But seeing the value of a life is not the same as seeing every life at stake. In the very city Abraham tried to save, his nephew Lot faces a choice of his own when two strangers arrive at his door. Lot welcomes them into his home, but his neighbors surround the house and demand that he bring the visitors outside so they can sexually assault them. To protect his guests, Lot offers his daughters instead. The angels intervene before the crowd can carry out its threat, but Lot has already revealed what he is willing to sacrifice. His determination to prevent one wrong has left him prepared to commit another.
Later, the Torah brings this tension into Abraham’s own home, when the man who argued so persistently for strangers is told to sacrifice his son. This time there is no negotiation. Abraham rises early and sets out to do what God has asked, without making the argument he was willing to make for Sodom.
The Torah praises Abraham for not withholding Isaac, and his willingness to give up so much remains one of its most difficult expressions of faith. Yet the same man who proves his devotion by preparing to sacrifice his son has already shown us a relationship with God in which he can argue for the lives of others. The Torah preserves both Abrahams, leaving us to admire the depth of his faith while confronting how differently that faith can be expressed.
In the next scene, Isaac is spared, and a ram takes his place. But the consequences reach beyond the mountain. Rashi connects Sarah’s death to hearing that her son had nearly been sacrificed. Abraham does not lose the child he was prepared to sacrifice, but instead loses a life that had never appeared to be part of the bargain. We can be so absorbed in the sacrifice we believe is required that we fail to see what else we are giving up.
The haftarah gives us two more parents facing the loss of their children. First, a widow comes to Elisha because a creditor is threatening to take her two sons as payment for her husband’s debts. Elisha helps her turn the little oil she has into enough to pay what she owes and keep her children. Later, a woman who had been promised a son by Elisha loses him, and Elisha brings him back to life. Read alongside the binding of Isaac, these stories offer another picture of what faith can make possible. The debt is paid and the children remain with their mother, while the promised son is restored to his. The future continues without requiring the parents to give up the children who were meant to inherit it.
With AI, we do not yet know the full extent of what we might gain or what it might cost. The promise is easier to pursue than the consequences are to understand. We can decide that a risk is worth taking long before we know what we have agreed to give up.
Our faith in progress can leave us with the same blind spot as Abraham. We may be prepared to accept certain dangers for the future we hope to build, while failing to recognize other things we are putting at risk. The question is not only whether progress will be worth its cost. It is whether we will recognize that cost while we can still choose what to preserve.
